Assess the research
Consider whether the research question, methods, analysis and conclusions are presented clearly and supported by the material provided.
Understand the general principles of careful, constructive and responsible research assessment.
These are draft reviewer guidance principles. The final reviewer workflow, timelines and requirements will be confirmed by the publishing team.
Consider whether the research question, methods, analysis and conclusions are presented clearly and supported by the material provided.
Explain major concerns clearly, distinguish essential revisions from optional suggestions, and keep feedback professional and respectful.
Treat unpublished manuscripts and associated materials as confidential and do not share them outside the authorized review process.
Inform the editorial team about relevant conflicts or limitations that may affect your ability to assess the manuscript impartially.
Understand the general principles of careful, constructive and responsible research assessment.
These are draft reviewer guidance principles. The final reviewer workflow, timelines and requirements will be confirmed by the publishing team.
Consider whether the research question, methods, analysis and conclusions are presented clearly and supported by the material provided.
Explain major concerns clearly, distinguish essential revisions from optional suggestions, and keep feedback professional and respectful.
Treat unpublished manuscripts and associated materials as confidential and do not share them outside the authorized review process.
Inform the editorial team about relevant conflicts or limitations that may affect your ability to assess the manuscript impartially.